Review: Toy Story 4 (2019)




As I said when I looked at another belated Pixar instalment, that company’s not exactly the guarantee of pedigree it used to be. The aforementioned Incredibles II was decent, but definitely not as memorable as the first one, despite a fifteen year gap—and while there have been successes here and there, I did raise an eyebrow when, nearly a decade after the conclusion of its trilogy, Pixar returned to the series that put it on the map.

1995’s Toy Story was a landmark—propelling CG animation into the forefront, while wisely using the medium to its strength by making it about things that actually look plastic, and telling a simple but well-written story of action figures, psychotic kids, and high explosives. 1999’s Toy Story 2 was arguably even better, touching on all the questions of obsolescence that come with these plastic products, and it all paid off with 2010’s Toy Story 3. Here, it actually dealt with the animated playthings seeing their owner move away, and for those that grew up on the original, the climax was an absolute emotional maelstrom that left many nineties kids insisting something was in their eyes.

And so, with story and themes so neatly tied up, I must admit, I was kind of cynical and skeptical when they came back to it with a fourth part--what the hell more was there to do, besides grab some extra box office cash? And you know what? This turns out to be Pixar’s best film that they’ve made in recent times, that I’ve seen anyway.

Tom Hanks returns as Woody, the fifties cowboy figure—who here hasn’t adjusted well to his new life with Bonnie, the little girl that inherited the toys at the end of the last film. Not the happiest of outcomes given the value he had to his last one, but considering the attention span of six year olds, all too realistic. Nevertheless, he does his best to perform the same ‘duties’ of being around for her, down to picking up a toy of her own creation—a sentient spork (er, as you do), voiced by Tony Hale. Forky, as he becomes known, has a bit of an existential confusion, and after throwing himself out of a moving RV truck, sets off what seems like another whimsical little adventure, like what you might see on a TV special.

It gets deeper than that, fortunately. Before long, Woody’s meeting old shepherdess figurine friend Bo (Annie Potts), not seen since the second film, who has a hell of a makeover as a protector of toys in a moving carnival. The original cast besides Woody and Tim Allen’s Buzz Lightyear are somewhat sidelined (and Buzz is back to being a bit of a blockhead again for some reason), but the new additions are surprisingly enjoyable. Jordan Peele and Keegan-Michael Key appear as a pair of manic plushies, and hell, even Keanu Reeves appears playing a klutz for once—an eighties Canadian action figure, Duke Caboom. These new characters all get decent characterization and their own little arcs, and fit in nicely. Forky isn’t as developed as the teasers may have suggested, but he plays his part better than I was expecting from those.

There’s a ‘villain’ of sorts, but fortunately, it doesn’t fall into the same setup as the last two, which did sort of repetitively mimic the other in that regard. I guess one drawback is that for most of the film, the stakes and the drama definitely don’t feel as high or poignant as in the previous trilogy—it’s somewhat lighter, for good and for ill. Don’t expect the same punch as 2 or 3…until the climax there is, which becomes a hell of an rollercoaster of feelings. I must admit, I started maybe getting just a few onions stuck near my eyes.

The ending might not sit right with everyone, but it gives the movie purpose as an epilogue to the series as a whole, and drives all the overarching themes of purpose and past to a solid, defining conclusion. That sort of thing is what made Pixar so damn great back in the day, and I’m glad to see they’ve still got it. There’s humor, there’s charm—I might not put this movie alongside the first three, but those are very tough pedestals to reach, and it still proves a worthy companion to them all.

That being said, let’s just say this better be the proper ending, no kidding around, for realsies this time. Otherwise, I wouldn’t envy the writing room for scratching their scalps off in desperation next time.

Ultimately, Toy Story 4 is a pleasant surprise that overcame my eyerolls at the very idea, and if you were as skeptical as I was, give it a chance. Other animated series may run themselves into the ground, but this time, Pixar managed to cap off an already solid trilogy the best they could—where others keeled over, they fall, with style.

See you, polyester cowboy.

Comments